3i: Capital in Action

Sector

Asset Management

Background

Luke Bridgeman is a Portfolio Manager at Hosking Partners. We cover the unique circumstances that led to 3i's founding in postwar Britain, why it now invests its own balance sheet rather than raise private equity, and the importance of letting your winners run.

Cover

Date

August 28, 2024

Episode Number

180

Detailed Business Breakdown of 3i Group

Background / Overview

3i Group is a publicly-traded investment company listed on the London Stock Exchange, with a history dating back to 1945. Originally founded as the Industrial and Commercial Finance Corporation (ICFC) following recommendations from the Macmillan Commission (which included John Maynard Keynes), 3i was established to address the funding gap for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in the UK. The initial capital of GBP 15 million was provided by major British banks, positioning 3i as a hybrid debt-equity provider for growing businesses. Over the decades, it evolved from a regional lender to a global private equity player. Renamed Investors in Industry in 1983 (shortened to 3i), it went public in 1994 with a GBP 1.5 billion market cap and expanded internationally, raising third-party funds and engaging in buyouts, venture capital, and infrastructure investments.

The 2008 financial crisis marked a turning point, as 3i faced challenges from excessive leverage at both the holding company and portfolio levels, leading to a halving of its net asset value (NAV) and a dilutive nine-for-seven rights issue in 2009, raising GBP 700 million. Since 2011, under CEO Simon Borrows, 3i has undergone a radical transformation, abandoning third-party fundraising to focus exclusively on investing its own balance sheet. This shift has simplified operations, reduced staff and offices, and concentrated investments in mid-market companies (enterprise values of GBP 100-500 million) across consumer, healthcare, industrial technology, services, and software sectors. The company’s portfolio is now dominated by a single asset, Action, a Dutch non-food discount retailer, which accounts for over two-thirds of its private equity portfolio’s value.

Ownership / Fundraising / Recent Valuation

3i is a publicly-traded entity with no significant private equity sponsors, as its ownership is dispersed among public shareholders. The 2009 rights issue was a critical recapitalization event, but since then, 3i has not raised additional equity or third-party funds, relying instead on its balance sheet for investments. As of the latest data, 3i’s market capitalization is approximately GBP 30 billion, while its total investments are valued at GBP 22 billion, implying a premium of GBP 8 billion over its NAV. This premium reflects market confidence in 3i’s ability to realize investments at higher multiples than book value or the unrecognized value of its flagship asset, Action. The company maintains modest leverage at the holding company level, with more significant debt within portfolio companies like Action, but avoids excessive leverage to ensure liquidity and flexibility.

Key Products / Services / Value Proposition

3i operates as a private equity investor, acquiring and managing mid-market businesses with a focus on long-term value creation. Its primary “product” is its investment portfolio, with Action being the cornerstone. The value proposition of 3i lies in its ability to:

1. Identify and acquire undervalued mid-market companies with growth potential, leveraging sector expertise in consumer, healthcare, industrial technology, services, and software.
2. Provide patient capital, allowing winners like Action to compound over extended periods without the pressure to exit, unlike traditional private equity funds.
3. Enhance portfolio company performance through active governance, strategic bolt-on acquisitions, and disciplined capital allocation.

Action’s Value Proposition:

• Business Model: Action is a pan-European non-food discount retailer operating in 12 countries with approximately 2,600 stores. It sells low-priced items (two-thirds of its 6,000 SKUs are under EUR 2) across categories like decoration, DIY, garden, multimedia, sports, stationery, toys, food, drink, laundry, cleaning, personal care, and pet products.
• Unique Dynamics: Action’s model is built on scale economies shared with customers, offering prices 50% lower than competitors, which drives high like-for-like (LFL) sales growth and creates a competitive moat. Its assortment is dynamic, with 150 new SKUs introduced weekly and only 33% of the product range fixed, ensuring constant novelty. The negative working capital model (cash collected before supplier payments) and rapid store payback (8-9 months) enable self-funded growth.
• Financial Impact: Acquired in 2011 for GBP 106 million, Action’s turnover has grown from EUR 700 million to EUR 11 billion by 2023. 3i’s 55% stake is valued at GBP 14 billion, with GBP 2.9 billion in dividends received, yielding a 100x return on investment.

Segments and Revenue Model

3i’s operations are divided into two main segments:

1. Private Equity (Core Segment): Represents the bulk of 3i’s value, with investments valued at GBP 20 billion, of which Action constitutes over two-thirds (GBP 14 billion). The private equity portfolio focuses on mid-market buyouts in five sectors: consumer, healthcare, industrial technology, services, and software. Revenue is generated through capital gains on exits, dividends from portfolio companies (e.g., Action), and interest income from debt-like instruments.
2. Infrastructure Fund Management (Minor Segment): A slimmed-down business managing third-party infrastructure funds, generating fee income that covers 3i’s corporate overheads. This segment is small and not a significant driver of value.

Revenue Model:

• Private Equity: 3i generates revenue through:
• Capital Gains: Realized on exits, typically at a premium to carrying value (e.g., 1.5x uplift on average).
• Dividends: Portfolio companies like Action distribute cash, with Action alone returning GBP 2.9 billion since 2011.
• Interest Income: From hybrid debt-equity instruments in portfolio companies.
• Infrastructure: Fee-based revenue from managing third-party funds, covering operating costs.
• Action’s Revenue Model: Action generates revenue through high-volume, low-price retail sales, with 20% annual top-line growth driven by LFL sales (higher than GDP due to pricing advantage) and store expansion (330 new stores in 2023, targeting 4,700 total stores in Europe).

Splits and Mix

• Portfolio Mix:
• Private Equity: 91% of total investments (GBP 20 billion of GBP 22 billion).
• Infrastructure: ~9% (small but covers overheads).
• Action: 70% of private equity portfolio (GBP 14 billion of GBP 20 billion).
• Geographic Mix:
• Action operates in 12 European countries, with plans for two additional countries in 2024. 3i’s broader portfolio includes investments in Europe and the U.S., though Europe dominates due to Action.
• Customer Mix:
• Action targets price-sensitive consumers seeking everyday low-cost goods, benefiting from trade-down behavior in recessions.
• End-Market Mix:
• Action: Non-food discount retail (consumer goods).
• Other Portfolio: Healthcare, industrial technology, services, software (diversified but smaller scale).
• Mix Shifts:
• Action’s dominance has increased over time, from a modest position in 2011 to over two-thirds of the portfolio, reflecting 3i’s strategy of letting winners run.
• Infrastructure has been de-emphasized, with no new third-party fundraising.

KPIs

• Action:
• Store Count: ~2,600 stores, with 330 added in 2023.
• Revenue Growth: ~20% annually (LFL + store expansion).
• EBITDA Growth: Higher than revenue due to operating leverage.
• Store Payback: 8-9 months.
• White Space: Potential for 4,700 stores in Europe.
• 3i:
• Investment Pace: Targets GBP 750 million annually (4-7 deals), but recent years saw lower deployment, reflecting discipline.
• Portfolio Valuation: GBP 22 billion total, with GBP 20 billion in private equity.
• Dividend Yield: ~2%, modest but growing.
• Share Price Growth: From GBP 4 to GBP 30 over 10 years (7x return).

Headline Financials

Revenue Trajectory:

• Historical: 3i’s revenue is primarily from portfolio dividends and capital gains, with Action’s EUR 11 billion turnover (2023) being the largest contributor. Action’s revenue grew from EUR 700 million in 2011 to EUR 11 billion in 2023, a ~15x increase, driven by 20% annual growth (LFL + store expansion).
• Drivers:
• Volume: Action’s store count (2,600, +330 in 2023) and high LFL sales growth due to low prices.
• Pricing: Action’s 50% price advantage drives consumer demand, with two-thirds of SKUs under EUR 2.
• Geographic Expansion: Entry into one new country annually, with two planned for 2024.
• Negative Working Capital: Enables self-funded growth, reducing reliance on external capital.

Cost Trajectory / Operating Leverage:

• Fixed Costs: 3i’s corporate overheads (staff, offices) are covered by infrastructure fees, minimizing fixed cost drag. Action’s fixed costs include store leases and distribution centers, but scale economies reduce per-unit costs as store count grows.
• Variable Costs: Action’s variable costs (inventory, labor) are low due to bulk purchasing and efficient operations. The negative working capital model (paying suppliers after sales) enhances cash flow.
• Operating Leverage: Action’s EBITDA growth exceeds revenue growth due to fixed cost absorption over a larger store base. 3i’s streamlined operations (fewer staff, offices) enhance group-level leverage.

Profit Margins:

• Action: Not explicitly reported, but high EBITDA margins are implied by the 18.5x EBITDA multiple and rapid store payback (8-9 months). The negative working capital and low-price, high-volume model suggest strong gross margins.
• 3i: EBITDA margins are less relevant due to the investment company structure, but infrastructure fees ensure zero net operating cost at the holding level. Profitability is driven by portfolio returns (e.g., 100x on Action).

Capital Intensity and Allocation:

• Capital Intensity:
• Action: Low capital intensity due to negative working capital and rapid store payback (8-9 months). New stores require minimal upfront investment, and growth is self-funded.
• 3i: Moderate capital intensity, with GBP 750 million targeted annually for new investments or bolt-ons. The portfolio generates significant cash (e.g., GBP 2.9 billion from Action), reducing external capital needs.
• Capital Allocation:
• Reinvestment: 3i prioritizes reinvesting in existing portfolio companies (e.g., GBP 1 billion to increase Action stake by 20%, yielding 40% return). Bolt-on acquisitions for platform businesses (e.g., Royal Sanders) are also favored.
• Dividends: Modest 2% yield, acknowledging shareholder returns but prioritizing reinvestment.
• Discipline: Recent under-deployment (below GBP 750 million target) reflects a focus on quality over quantity, avoiding overpriced deals.

Free Cash Flow (FCF):

• Drivers:
• Dividends: GBP 2.9 billion from Action since 2011, with ongoing distributions due to Action’s leverage (borrowing to pay dividends).
• Exits: Realized at 1.5x book value on average, generating cash inflows.
• Capex: Low for Action (store openings self-funded). 3i’s capex is primarily new investments (GBP 750 million target).
• NWC: Action’s negative working capital (cash collected before supplier payments) enhances FCF. 3i’s holding company has minimal NWC requirements.
• Cash Conversion: Strong due to Action’s model and 3i’s low operating costs. FCF is reinvested or distributed as dividends.

Value Chain Position

• 3i: Operates as a capital allocator, acquiring and managing mid-market businesses. Its value-add lies in deal sourcing, due diligence, governance, and strategic growth (e.g., bolt-ons, geographic expansion). It is upstream in the private equity value chain, controlling portfolio companies but not engaging in day-to-day operations.
• Action: Midstream in the retail value chain, sourcing low-cost goods (branded and private label) from suppliers and selling directly to consumers through physical stores. Its competitive advantage is scale-driven low pricing, bulk purchasing, and efficient distribution.
• Go-to-Market (GTM) Strategy:
• 3i: Targets mid-market companies (GBP 100-500 million EV) with growth potential, leveraging sector expertise and relationships to source proprietary deals. Investments are held long-term, maximizing compounding.
• Action: Operates physical stores with a low-price, high-turnover model, targeting price-sensitive consumers. The dynamic assortment (150 new SKUs weekly) drives frequent visits, while pan-European scale enhances bargaining power with suppliers.

Customers and Suppliers

• 3i:
• Customers: Portfolio companies (e.g., Action) and infrastructure fund clients. Shareholders are the ultimate “customers,” benefiting from NAV growth and dividends.
• Suppliers: None in the traditional sense; 3i relies on internal expertise and deal flow from relationships.
• Action:
• Customers: Price-sensitive retail consumers seeking low-cost non-food goods. Benefits from trade-down behavior in recessions.
• Suppliers: Diverse global suppliers providing branded and private-label goods. Action’s scale enables bulk purchasing at low costs, strengthening supplier relationships.

Pricing

• 3i:
• Contract Structure: Long-term equity investments with no fixed duration. Exits are opportunistic, driven by valuation and strategic fit.
• Pricing Drivers: Portfolio valuations (e.g., Action at 18.5x EBITDA) reflect growth potential, runway, and competitive moats. Realized exits typically achieve 1.5x book value.
• Action:
• Pricing Strategy: Ultra-low pricing (two-thirds of SKUs under EUR 2), 50% cheaper than competitors, driving high volume and LFL growth.
• Drivers: Scale economies, bulk purchasing, and negative working capital enable low prices. Pricing is mission-critical, creating consumer surplus and loyalty.
• Contract Structure: Retail sales are transactional, with no long-term contracts. Supplier contracts are likely short-term, leveraging Action’s scale for favorable terms.

Bottoms-Up Drivers

Revenue Model & Drivers:

• 3i:
• Model: Generates revenue through portfolio dividends, capital gains, and infrastructure fees. The private equity segment drives value, with Action as the primary contributor.
• Volume: Limited to 4-7 deals annually (GBP 750 million), focusing on quality. Action’s store expansion (330 stores in 2023) drives portfolio revenue.
• Pricing: Portfolio valuations reflect EBITDA multiples (e.g., Action at 18.5x). Exits achieve 1.5x book value, reflecting 3i’s ability to enhance portfolio company value.
• Drivers: Long-term holding periods, disciplined deal selection, and bolt-on acquisitions. Action’s 20% revenue growth (LFL + expansion) is the dominant driver.
• Action:
• Model: High-volume, low-price retail sales, with 20% annual growth from LFL sales and store openings.
• Volume: 2,600 stores, adding 330 in 2023, with potential for 4,700 in Europe. High LFL growth due to low prices and dynamic assortment.
• Pricing: 50% cheaper than competitors, driven by scale, bulk purchasing, and efficient operations. Low prices create a moat, deterring competition.
• Drivers:
• Industry Fundamentals: Discount retail benefits from trade-down behavior in recessions and price sensitivity.
• Scale Economies: Pan-European operations reduce per-unit costs, enabling low prices.
• Switching Costs: Low for consumers, but Action’s pricing and assortment create loyalty.
• End-Market Growth: Non-food discount retail grows faster than GDP due to pricing advantage.

Cost Structure & Drivers:

• 3i:
• Fixed Costs: Corporate overheads (staff, offices) covered by infrastructure fees, minimizing cost drag. Investment committee and due diligence costs are fixed but streamlined.
• Variable Costs: Minimal, as 3i does not produce goods. Deal-related costs (e.g., legal, advisory) vary with investment pace.
• Operating Leverage: High, as fixed costs are covered by fees, and portfolio growth (e.g., Action) drives NAV without proportional cost increases.
• Action:
• Fixed Costs: Store leases, distribution centers, and management. Scale economies reduce per-store fixed costs as the network grows.
• Variable Costs: Inventory, labor, and logistics. Bulk purchasing and efficient operations keep variable costs low.
• Operating Leverage: Strong, as fixed costs are spread over a growing store base, boosting EBITDA margins. Negative working capital enhances cash flow.
• Contribution Margin: High, given low variable costs and rapid store payback (8-9 months).

FCF Drivers:

• 3i:
• Net Income: Driven by portfolio dividends (e.g., GBP 2.9 billion from Action) and capital gains (1.5x book value on exits).
• Capex: GBP 750 million annually for new investments or bolt-ons, considered growth capex. Maintenance capex is minimal.
• NWC: Minimal at the holding level, as 3i’s operations are lean.
• Cash Conversion: Strong, with cash inflows from dividends and exits funding reinvestment and modest dividends (2% yield).
• Action:
• Net Income: High EBITDA margins flow to net income, enhanced by leverage (borrowing to pay dividends).
• Capex: Low, as store openings are self-funded with 8-9 month payback.
• NWC: Negative, with cash collected before supplier payments, boosting FCF.
• Cash Conversion: Exceptional, enabling GBP 2.9 billion in dividends to 3i since 2011.

Capital Deployment:

• Reinvestment: 3i prioritizes existing portfolio companies (e.g., GBP 1 billion to increase Action stake, 40% return). Bolt-on acquisitions (e.g., Royal Sanders) leverage platform businesses.
• Dividends: Modest 2% yield, balancing shareholder returns with growth.
• M&A: Disciplined, targeting 4-7 deals annually but under-deploying recently to avoid overpaying. Focus on mid-market buyouts with 15%+ returns and EBITDA >100 million.
• Synergies: Bolt-ons enhance scale and margins in platform businesses, while Action’s organic growth requires no M&A.

Market, Competitive Landscape, Strategy

Market Size and Growth:

• Private Equity: The global private equity market is valued at ~$4-5 trillion (AUM), with mid-market buyouts (EV $100-500 million) representing a smaller but less competitive segment. Growth is driven by demand for alternative assets and SME financing.
• Discount Retail (Action): The European non-food discount retail market is estimated at ~EUR 100-150 billion, growing at 5-7% annually due to price sensitivity and trade-down behavior. Action’s 20% growth far exceeds the market, driven by store expansion and LFL sales.
• Industry Growth Stack:
• Population growth: ~0.5% in Europe.
• Real GDP growth: ~1-2%.
• Inflation: ~2-3%.
• Consumer trends: Rising demand for low-cost goods, boosting discount retail.

Market Structure:

• Private Equity: Fragmented, with thousands of firms globally. The mid-market is less competitive, as larger players (e.g., KKR, Blackstone) target bigger deals. 3i’s focus on mid-market buyouts and proprietary deal flow gives it an edge.
• Discount Retail: Consolidated in Europe, with players like Aldi, Lidl, and dollar stores. Action’s 50% price advantage creates a unique niche, with limited direct competitors at its price point.

Competitive Positioning:

• 3i: Positioned as a disciplined, countercyclical investor in the mid-market, avoiding the pro-cyclical fundraising treadmill. Its balance sheet model and long-term holding strategy differentiate it from traditional private equity funds.
• Action: Positioned as the lowest-cost non-food discounter in Europe, with a 50% price advantage and scale-driven moat. Competes against dollar stores and supermarkets but occupies a unique price-quality niche.

Market Share & Relative Growth:

• 3i: Small player in global private equity but a leader in European mid-market buyouts due to expertise and deal flow. Its portfolio growth (driven by Action) outpaces the broader market.
• Action: Significant share in European non-food discount retail, with EUR 11 billion in turnover. Its 20% growth far exceeds the market’s 5-7%, driven by store expansion and LFL sales.

Competitive Forces (Hamilton’s 7 Powers Analysis):

1. Economies of Scale:
• 3i: Streamlined operations and infrastructure fees cover fixed costs, enabling high operating leverage. Mid-market focus reduces competition.
• Action: Pan-European scale reduces per-unit costs, enabling 50% lower prices. Rapid store payback (8-9 months) enhances scalability.
2. Network Effects: Limited for both 3i and Action, as private equity and retail lack direct network effects. However, Action’s scale creates indirect network effects through supplier bargaining power.
3. Branding: Minimal for 3i, as it targets institutional deals. Action’s brand is associated with ultra-low prices, driving consumer loyalty.
4. Counter-Positioning:
• 3i: Balance sheet model avoids fundraising cycles, enabling countercyclical investing and long-term holds. Competitors are constrained by fund lifecycles.
• Action: Low-price, high-turnover model is difficult for higher-cost retailers to replicate without sacrificing margins.
5. Cornered Resource:
• 3i: Proprietary deal flow in mid-market buyouts, built on relationships and expertise.
• Action: Scale-driven cost advantage and negative working capital model are unique in discount retail.
6. Process Power:
• 3i: Disciplined investment process (tightened post-2008) ensures high-quality deals and governance.
• Action: Efficient store rollout (330 stores in 2023) and dynamic assortment (150 new SKUs weekly) drive operational excellence.
7. Switching Costs:
• 3i: High for portfolio companies due to governance and capital structure control.
• Action: Low for consumers, but pricing and assortment create habitual purchasing.

Porter’s Five Forces:

1. New Entrants: Low threat for 3i (capital-intensive, expertise-driven) and Action (scale and pricing moat deter entry).
2. Substitutes: Moderate for 3i (other asset classes) and Action (online retail, but low prices mitigate threat).
3. Supplier Power: Low for 3i (deal flow is proprietary) and Action (scale enables favorable supplier terms).
4. Buyer Power: Low for 3i (portfolio companies rely on 3i’s capital) and Action (price-sensitive consumers have few alternatives).
5. Industry Rivalry: Moderate for 3i (less competition in mid-market) and Action (unique pricing reduces direct rivalry).

Strategic Logic:

• 3i: Focuses on mid-market buyouts with a long-term holding strategy, leveraging balance sheet flexibility to avoid pro-cyclicality. Disciplined capital allocation (under-deployment recently) and bolt-on acquisitions enhance portfolio value.
• Action: Pursues aggressive store expansion (330 stores in 2023, targeting 4,700) and LFL growth through low pricing and dynamic assortment. Scale economies and negative working capital drive self-funded growth.
• Minimum Efficient Scale (MES): 3i’s MES is achieved through its streamlined operations and mid-market focus, avoiding diseconomies of scale. Action’s MES is large due to pan-European scale, creating a defensible position.

Valuation

• Market Cap: GBP 30 billion, a GBP 8 billion premium over NAV (GBP 22 billion).
• NAV Breakdown:
• Private Equity: GBP 20 billion (Action: GBP 14 billion, 55% stake).
• Infrastructure/Other: GBP 2 billion.
• Action Valuation: 18.5x run-rate EBITDA with a 5% liquidity discount, lower than Costco (33x) but higher than Walmart/Home Depot (15x). Reflects Action’s growth runway (4,700 potential stores) and competitive moat.
• Premium Justification:
• Historical exits at 1.5x book value suggest NAV undervalues assets.
• Action’s growth (20% annually) and moat (50% price advantage) warrant a higher multiple.
• 3i’s disciplined capital allocation and countercyclical strategy enhance investor confidence.
• Comparables:
• Private Equity: Onex (balance sheet model), but 3i’s Action dominance is unique.
• Retail: Costco (scale-driven moat, 33x EBITDA), Walmart (15x). Action’s 18.5x is reasonable given its growth and risk profile.
• Risks:
• Concentration Risk: Action’s dominance (70% of private equity portfolio) makes 3i vulnerable to Action’s performance.
• Key Man Risk: CEO Simon Borrows (age 65) is critical, though the firm’s culture is entrenched.
• Geographic Expansion: Potential U.S. entry for Action carries risks, given historical failures of European retailers.

Key Takeaways and Unique Dynamics

1. Balance Sheet Model:
• Uniqueness: 3i’s decision to abandon third-party fundraising in 2011, investing solely its own balance sheet, is rare in private equity. This avoids the pro-cyclical fundraising treadmill, enabling countercyclical deal-making and long-term holds.
• Impact: Allows 3i to let winners like Action compound (100x return since 2011) without exit pressure. Generates higher absolute returns (e.g., GBP 250 million vs. GBP 50 million from fees) by retaining full upside.
• Dynamic: Breaks the traditional private equity cycle of raising, investing, and exiting within fund lifecycles, aligning incentives with shareholders.
2. Action’s Scale-Driven Moat:
• Uniqueness: Action’s 50% price advantage, negative working capital, and rapid store payback (8-9 months) create a self-reinforcing flywheel. Its pan-European scale and dynamic assortment (150 new SKUs weekly) deter competitors.
• Impact: 20% annual revenue growth (LFL + expansion) and high EBITDA margins drive 3i’s NAV. The GBP 14 billion valuation reflects a 100x return on GBP 106 million invested.
• Dynamic: Scale economies shared with customers (low prices) widen the moat, while negative working capital funds growth, reducing capital needs.
3. Disciplined Capital Allocation:
• Uniqueness: 3i’s focus on mid-market buyouts (GBP 100-500 million EV) and under-deployment (below GBP 750 million target) reflect a quality-over-quantity approach. Reinvestment in known assets (e.g., GBP 1 billion for Action stake, 40% return) maximizes returns.
• Impact: Avoids overpaying in hot markets, enhancing long-term NAV growth. Bolt-on acquisitions (e.g., Royal Sanders) leverage platform businesses.
• Dynamic: Countercyclical investing and long-term holds exploit market inefficiencies, particularly in the less competitive mid-market.
4. Operating Leverage and Cash Flow:
• Uniqueness: Action’s negative working capital and low capital intensity enable self-funded growth, while 3i’s infrastructure fees cover fixed costs, creating high group-level leverage.
• Impact: Action’s GBP 2.9 billion in dividends and 3i’s strong FCF support reinvestment and modest dividends (2% yield).
• Dynamic: Scale-driven cost efficiencies and cash conversion create a virtuous cycle of growth and returns.
5. Governance and Long-Term Focus:
• Uniqueness: 3i’s governance of portfolio companies (e.g., Action’s board) is stronger than typical public retailers, shielding management from short-term pressures.
• Impact: Enables strategic decisions like Action’s aggressive expansion and dynamic assortment, driving sustained growth.
• Dynamic: Long-term ownership aligns management with shareholders, fostering disciplined growth.

Conclusion

3i Group’s business model is a unique blend of private equity discipline and retail compounding, driven by its balance sheet approach and the dominance of Action. The shift away from third-party fundraising has enabled countercyclical investing and long-term holds, maximizing returns from winners like Action (100x since 2011). Action’s scale-driven moat, negative working capital, and rapid store payback create a self-reinforcing growth engine, while 3i’s disciplined capital allocation and governance enhance portfolio value. The GBP 8 billion premium over NAV reflects market confidence in Action’s runway and 3i’s strategy, though concentration and key man risks warrant monitoring. This model exemplifies the power of aligning incentives, leveraging scale, and prioritizing long-term value creation.

Transcript